Real journalism for a change
by Transmontanus, 7 September 2008
Taliban leader Haji Namdar: “The army comes in, and they fire at empty buildings. It is a drama — it is just to entertain.” The NYT’s Dexter Filkins: “Entertain whom?” Namdar: “America.”

Late in June, to great fanfare, the Pakistani military began what it described as a decisive offensive to rout the Taliban from Khyber agency, one of seven tribal areas that make up the FATA. “Forces Move In on Militants,” declared a headline in Dawn, one of Pakistan’s most influential newspapers. Reporters were kept away, but footage on Pakistani television showed troops advancing behind trucks and troop carriers. The Americans were pleased.
. . . A few days into the military operation, the photographer Lynsey Addario and I, dressed in traditional clothes and with a posse of gunmen protecting us, rode into Khyber agency ourselves. “Entry by Foreigners Prohibited Beyond This Point,” the sign said on the way in. As we drove past the dun-colored buildings and corrugated-tin shops, every trace of government authority vanished. No policemen, no checkpoints, no guards. Nothing to keep us from our appointment with the Taliban.
Filkins’ full account is here. It is proper reporting.
This is what journalism is for.




Monday 8 September 2008 at 15:08
Over on New English Review is an article that reports a Pakistani army officer as saying that the whole thing is a way of extorting money from the West. The Pakistani economy would collapse without the billions pumped in by the Yanks.