The dry creekbed of ’supply-side’ economics
by hakmao, 27 May 2008
On Sunday South African President Thabo Mbeki finally spoke out against the murderous xenophobic violence perpetrated against migrants and refugees in South Africa, a great number of whom, it should be noted, have fled the violence, oppression and starvation in neighbouring Zimbabwe–on which he remains silent.
The violence against the weak and the vulnerable–which has seen the return of the abominable practice of ‘necklacing’–is worse than deplorable, although it is not unfathomable if you look beneath the veneer of the post-Apartheid state. The prescription as advocated by various Western liberals–and increasingly–governments, was simple: enfranchise the population and all else will follow.
As has become increasingly obvious to anyone paying attention since 1994, national liberation is not sufficient–it is not enough to hand power from one elite to another and wait for things to take care of themselves, as the gulf between the poor and the middle class widens in an expanding economy–there is now a greater distribution of inequality. The problems of atomisation and increasing stratification of wealth and class are not confined to South Africa, although the effects and levels of poverty are particularly acute–as the poor of the townships direct their anger not at the ruling class, but on those who have even less than they do.
If things have not changed for the majority, it is evident that little has changed in the Afrikaaner heartland either. Simon Reeve, visiting the town of Louis Trichardt remarked that things appear to have changed dramatically–the town centre was previously the domain of white farmers–however, appearances are deceiving, as Boer militias train with assault weapons in the bush in order that they are ready to ‘handle’ any serious attempt to overturn existing social relations. Reeve, shooting an AK47, said the experience made him feel strangely powerful–to which his Boer host responded with great candour ‘that’s the problem’, ie the power which emanates from the barrel of the gun undermines the ‘natural’ ‘authority’ of the white farmer. Later Reeve showed disgusting, bloated Boer vigilante pigs patrolling the border, having arrogated to themselves the authority to stop and search people, before trussing them with plasticuffs to be returned to starvation.
The South African experience is a text book example of the failure of the neo-liberal economic model to address the problems of states on the periphery of capitalism, although what else could the ANC have done but become part of the global economy? You cannot have socialism in one country. The root cause of the impotence of the ANC government is South Africa’s subservient position as a former outpost of imperialism.
In conclusion–No One Is Illegal.




Wednesday 28 May 2008 at 22:09
Poor second half to your post
Change your last line to this:
“The root cause of the impotence of the Zanu PF government is Zimbabwe’s subservient position as a former outpost of imperialism”
and you see how lazy you’re being.
by suggesting that the ‘root causes’ (’root causes’ - lazy Stalinist language) of the impotence of the SA govt are a hangover from ‘imperialism’ basically abrogates the ANC of any responsibility.
is it because they’re black?
it is not south africa’s position as ‘a former outpost of imperialism’ that is responsible for its current problems - rather the myriad failed policies of the ANC government; its policy towards Zimbabwe/Mugabe chief among them.
and where do you find language like: “any serious attempts to overturn existing social relations.’
how does one overturn social relations?
what on earth does that mean?
as for this: “disgusting, bloated Boer vigilante pigs patrolling the border,” - have not seen the BBC film, but I seriously doubt these farmers are armed in order to send fleeing Zimbabweans back across the border.
I suspect the film maker has used it as a cheap shot. far more likely these Boers are armed because more than 2000 of them have been murdered in South Africa since 1994 - a situation the ANC has done little to stop, instead blaming it on crime. well the same crime is now responsible for the violent wave of criminal xenophobia which you are against.
who knows, if the migrants being attacked in South Africa were to arm themselves with AK47s to defend themselves perhaps you would accuse them of resisting attempts to overturn existing social relations.
stop patronizing black Africans and insulting white ones.
it makes you sound like the imperialist.