Wild China

by Jura Watchmaker, 12 May 2008

Last night I thought about writing something about the BBC documentary series Wild China that has just started its six-episode run. But events in China have taken a catastrophic turn in the form of a very wild natural event that is reported to have resulted in the deaths of thousands.

Unlike in Burma, the Chinese authorities are known for their skill in dealing with natural disasters such as the 7.8 magnitude earthquake that hit Sichuan province early this morning. Let’s hope that all goes well with the emergency effort, and there are no aftershocks that take further lives.

The first episode of wildlife film producer Phil Chapman’s documentary broadcast yesterday was superb, and I’m looking forward very much to the rest of the series. The dead tree edition of the Radio Times this week describes the film as “sumptuous”, and for very good reason. Chapman says that there was a lot of negotiation involved between himself and the Chinese state broadcaster, which is ever wary of foreigners. Says Chapman:

Our greatest misconception of the country is that it’s military-dominated, industrialised, trashed, with a cowed population. Well, it just isn’t like that. China’s a big, beautiful country, with amazing people, most of whom don’t give a shit about Beijing or politics. I was expecting a much more guarded, fearful society, but that couldn’t be further from the truth. Once you’re in, it’s hard not to fall in love with the place.”

It sounds like the kind of place I should see for myself. What Chapman says is no doubt correct, and those of us who spend much time criticising China for its state capitalist dictatorship would do well to remember this and keep a sense of perspective. Totalitarianism is a complex beast.

Comments

  1. neil

    Almost any statement of the form: X is Y is at best a partial truth when X is sufficiently large and complex, and Y is a broad enough concept.

    You know the sort of statement: America is … . It may be true. But America is sufficiently large and complex that it is true at the same time that other, almost contradictory statements are true as well. The same issue applies to China.

    Essentially China is X and China is Y are both true, depending on where and when you look and who you talk to.

    Or you could say that China is everything, all at once.

  2. Jura Watchmaker

    The point is that there is a human interest – both in the earthquake and in more general terms – which should not be obscured by political considerations. Phil Chapman is doing us a great service in portraying China in wider aspect than we are used to from news reports. And I think he deserves some credit for that.

    I’ve done my bit of Beijing-bashing in this web lodge. But for now I’m simply trying to express some solidarity with the Chinese people, and state that through documentaries such as Chapman’s I hope to learn much more about the vast country and its many and varied populations.

  3. neil

    Good. I’ll try and download it to my iplayer.

    As someone said opinions of a country’s government should never temper your opinion of the country.