More Yuletide Cheer
by Transmontanus, 13 December 2007
I’m a bit too steamed about things at the moment to just post a response in comments here, so I’m opening a poppet valve here instead.
For one, wishing someone Merry Christmas isn’t ignorant. It’s what people who celebrate Christmas do. In the past week or so, a half-dozen people have said “Happy Hanukkah” to me, and these people are not ignorant. And people who don’t know the difference between a burqa and a hijab aren’t ignorant people, either. They’re just people who don’t know the difference between a burqa and a hijab.
Canadians can be just as ignorant as Americans, though. In the few hours since this appeared, I’ve been dismissed as a racist and a Zionist. But ignorance is all over the place. Five mouseclicks will get you from a blank Google search screen to a site that blames Zionists for the Irish bloody famine.
But no, you can’t equate the depth of Americans’ ignorance of the world (and even of the continent they’re on) with the level of ignorance on similar subjects among Canadians. The distance between these two levels of ignorance is enormous.
That much I will say in my Constable Transmontanus, Royal Canadian Thought Police voice.
Heres’ what I have to say in my Johnny Canuck voice.
In my offending post on this site, I even apologized for Celine Dion, for Christ’s sake. Plus I said Canada wasn’t better, just different. Plus in the column I linked to, when I referred to Britain and France and Americaland, I wrote: “These countries are better than us in many ways.” So lighten the fuck up.
I admit that I came to the column with a bit of attitude. I’d just read that “Toothless Canada Borrows Crescent Fangs” essay Abe Greenwald wrote in Jewcy, a webzine I think is otherwise terrific, and it occurred to me I am fed up to the teeth of hearing Yankees sneer, shout and snigger about what we’re trying to do up here. They’re no better than Canadians who think Americans have smaller brains than us.
Still, I have to confess that I’m sick and tired of the kind of Americans who give out of themselves about “Soviet Canuckistan” and I’m sick and tired of Americans who imagine that Canadians are just Americans with no guns and a good health care plan, and if I encounter one more American who comes up here and pats us on the head and says “thanks for helping us in Afghanistan” as if our soldiers are dying in the fucking dust of that country just to help Americans I’ll put his teeth down his throat for him. And I’m also sick to my stomach of Americans who use my country like some kind of white liberal gated community to which they think they are by some magic entitled to resort without so much as a by-your-leave every time their countrymen elect some goofball president they don’t like. Go home.
We’re involved in a massive experiment up here. We’ve got the highest rates of immigration in the world, and ninety percent of our Muslims are foreign-born, and a civil national conversation is difficult for us to maintain at the best of times, being bilingual and all, and it doesn’t help being strung out across the top of the most vibrant cultural dynamo in the history of nation states with a population ten times our own. Nevertheless, so far, it’s working out pretty well.
We screw up all the time. But when it comes to free speech and “race relations” and immigration, we don’t need lectures from Americans, thank you very much. On these these subjects, it just might be best if Americans busied themselves with their own affairs and left us alone and shut their big yappers.
There. I feel better now.
Sorry for the intemperate language. I realize bad words are frowned upon at this blog.
Sorry.




