Does truth matter?
by Scoop Shachtman, 1 October 2007
My last post led to a very strange comment from the owner of a peculiar and obsessive site.
One of the imagined maladies he projects on those he must secretly admire is telepathy. I suspect the reason he does this is because he thinks he has the ability himself. Perhaps he thinks he is a character in Heroes.
Because, apparently, posting a link to a story about the Muhammad al-Durrah picture, and the possibility that all is not as it seems, means I am comparable to Little Green Footballs, or Melanie Phillips (Johann Hari’s standards, but of the right). Both of which are Godwin’s Law-style embarrassments, when it comes to blog debates. A bit like someone shouting “You smell!” in the school playground.
In addition, he also implies that my post is in some way a mechanism to whitewash the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). In fact, my position would be that if a 12 year-old boy was deliberately targeted by IDF troops then they should be held accountable by a court of law. My only concern is whether there is doubt over what happened in the al-Durrah picture.
Or does it not matter? Have we come to the stage that the al-Durrah picture is “true”, regardless of what may actually have happened?



